Myths about Self-Driving Cars Debunked: Part One

Myths About Self-Driving Cars Debunked: Part 1

Max Greene

Self-driving cars feel like the stuff of science fiction. Ten years ago, who would’ve thought that today we’d be seeing headlines like People keep rear-ending self-driving cars in the Bay Area? But here we are – that headline is real, and so are self-driving cars.

Given the speed at which self-driving cars are joining conventional vehicles on the road already, it’s important to address some myths about them. Only by getting at what’s really happening right now can we make sensible plans for how self-driving cars can be safely and sensibly integrated into New England’s transportation network.

We’ll debunk five common myths altogether, with the first two tackled here. For the second part of our series, click here.

Myth # 1: Self-Driving Cars Are Still A Long Way Off

Actually, self-driving cars are here now. Remember how people keep rear-ending self-driving cars in the Bay Area? Well, you don’t even need to go as far as California to find self-driving cars on the road: autonomous-vehicle companies nuTonomy, Optimus Ride, and Delphi are already testing self-driving cars on the streets of Boston (without the rear-end collisions). Lyft reportedly plans to test self-driving cars in the city this fall. And Rhode Island is getting ready to enter the fray, too

While self-driving cars are being tested in New England, they’re on the verge of full deployment outside the United States. In a matter of just months, nuTonomy plans to launch a fleet of self-driving taxis in Singapore. The United States won’t be far behind.

That means we can’t wait to figure out how self-driving cars will work on our roadways. We need to plan for the widespread adoption of this innovative new technology now.

Myth # 2: Self-Driving Cars Will Reduce Traffic Jams

Google co-founder Sergey Brin has said that self-driving cars “will improve the community” by “reducing congestion,” but there’s plenty of reason to expect that self-driving cars will actually increase traffic – unless we tackle the traffic issue proactively. Researchers generally agree that the more self-driving cars are on the road, the more overall miles will be driven.

One study estimates that “system-wide VMT [vehicle-miles traveled] could experience 37% growth.” If you add up the total miles that every car, SUV, and truck in the United States spends on the road every year, then increase it by a whopping 37%, that’s hardly a recipe for fewer traffic jams.

What’s more, another study suggests a 60% increase is possible. Still another finds that if commuters decide to opt for shared self-driving cars instead of buses, overall miles traveled could increase by 90%. There are many reasons for this predicted increase, including the convenience of self-driving cars, lower driving costs, and the prospect of greater access for more people – in particular, young people without a license, seniors who can no longer drive, and people with disabilities.

While the relationship between miles traveled and congestion isn’t totally straightforward, there’s no question that increasing miles traveled means that cars will be out on the road more, which will tend to increase congestion. One solution is to limit or charge a fee for miles that zombie vehicles (self-driving cars without passengers) drive.

(Why would a self-driving car be on the road without a passenger? Think of someone running into the grocery store and having their car drive around the block while they’re inside rather than parking it. Or a Lyft or Uber car driving around a popular pick-up spot while waiting for a pick-up.)

Making it illegal or expensive to let an empty car drive endlessly will reduce overall miles traveled and, therefore, congestion. That’s why we’ve supported a bill that would accomplish just that in Massachusetts.

Part Two: Pollution, Proliferation, and Safety

There’s a lot more to say about self-driving cars, which you can find in part two – including the idea that self-driving cars will cut air and carbon pollution and that they’re not as safe as cars with drivers. In the meantime, to stay up to date on how you can support legislation that helps us prepare for our self-driving future, sign up for CLF action alerts here.


About the CLF Blog

The views and opinions expressed on this blog do not necessarily represent the opinions or positions of Conservation Law Foundation, our boards, or our supporters.